Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD student in Architecture, Tabriz University of Islamic Arts. Iran

2 Master of architectural engineering. Architecture Department of ACECR, Hamedan Branch, Hamedan,Iran

3 Assistant Professor of Engineering , Bu-Ali Sina University , Hamedan, Iran

Abstract

 
A successful urban space has a wide range of subjective and objective components, and paying attention to physical indicators plays a decisive role in creating a "successful" place. One of its strategies is the development of pedestrian zones in cities. This research has been carried out in search of the answer to what factors can contribute to the success of pedestrianization projects and place development. This article deals with the comparative analysis of the pedestrianization project of two streets leading to the central square of Hamedan City before and after implementation to investigate the qualitative and quantitative components of the place. The research method combines qualitative and quantitative methods, and observations, interviews, and questionnaires are used to collect information, along with library and documentary studies. The research findings indicate that in this case study, unlike sociability, the three indicators of accessibility, uses and activities, comfort and mental image creation have not improved much. In addition to that, there is a strong relationship between interconnectedness and sociability. Furthermore, improving the quality of the place cannot be done in a one-dimensional way and with a narrow view of specific components. It requires that pedestrianization projects are implemented considering all the components.
Keywords: Pedestrian Zone, Successful Place, PPS Matrix, Spatial Arrangement, Urban Square.
 
 
 
Introduction
Extensive studies in the field of pedestrianization implementation have become a new topic in the development of Iran.  Most of these researches are in three categories: 1- feasibility studies, 2- evaluation of the social effects of the implementation of such projects, and 3- providing solutions to carry out this process. Studies have been conducted on various social, historical and urban design consequences. The commonality of the current research is in the investigation of the spatial components of pedestrian construction with these investigations, and its special place among these studies is the measurement of the qualitative components of the pedestrian place with a comparative approach to investigate the quality success.
Methodology
This practical research is considered a subset of qualitative and quantitative analysis. To answer the research question, that is, how and to what extent pedestrianization can lead to the improvement of the quality components of the place, and to collect the required information, in addition to library and document studies using tools and analysis, and observing primary qualitative information through review, observations, identification, descriptions and characteristics of the study area (Imam plaza) were done in terms of the environment. Then, interviews were started by distributing questionnaires among the people using the study area. The questions were set by putting the sociability items in the PPS matrix and using the Delphi method. In the end, the answers were explained. Due to these, urban sidewalks are one of the urban public places, and the opinion of urban field experts about the success of an urban public place, the PPS matrix was the closest model to these components. Furthermore, a quantitative measurement tool was needed to analyze space syntax to clarify the hidden dimensions of the components of the place in the qualitative investigation.
Results & Discussion
The findings indicate a special relationship between the correlation index in quantitative analysis and the qualitative sociability index. As a result, the quantitative test confirms the results of the qualitative analysis regarding the promotion of sociability in the field of Bu-Ali after the implementation. The reason for this is the higher macro-intermediate connection in Bu-Ali compared to Ekbatan. This is despite the local connection being more in Ekbatan than Bu-Ali. It shows the ratio of comparisons of sociability with connectivity in the two axes of Bu-Ali and Ekbatan before and after the implementation of pedestrianization. It also confirms the relevance and complementarity of qualitative and quantitative research presented in previous studies and knowledge.
Conclusions
It shows examples of holistic and not reductive urban design to create a "successful" place. It also states that a quality and sustainable design cannot highlight one aspect and expect growth in full force. The development of pedestrianization should consider the use of land and buildings as well as urban infrastructure and "access and links, comfort and image, applications and activities" in the design considerations. In future studies, other aspects, such as the economic component, can be addressed, and the current research results can be used for such scientific studies.

Keywords

 
Azkaei, Parviz (2001), Hamadan Namah (Twenty sayings about Madestan), Madestan Publishing House, 1st edition. [In Persian].
Speck, Jeff (2017). Translated by Dr. Hamed Mutzorzadeh and Dr. Vahidah Hojjati. Tahan Publications, Novet 1 [In Persian].
Tadayi, Mohammad Mahdi, (2015). The book of Hamedan's photo collection during the passage of time.. [In Persian]
Eliasi, Ebrahim, Zandieh, Mehdi, Mohammadi, Akam, (2015). Designing urban gardens with an emphasis on community development (case study: gardens in Mahabad city). Two Quarterly Journals of Manzar Shahr, Year 3/Number 6. [In Persian]
Ahri, Zahra, (2013). City, celebration, a memory of reflection on the relationship between urban spaces and celebrations during the Safavid and Qajar periods. Journal of fine arts, architecture and urban planning. No. 47. pp. 5-16. [In Persian]
Ismailpour, Najma, Saberifar, Rostam, Habibi, Mohammad Ali (2019). Prioritization of roads prone to pedestrian construction in the field of historical context of Yazd city using the analytical tool Weighted Sum in the geographic information system. Scientific Quarterly Journal of Urban Ecology Research. Year twelve, number 2, consecutive 24, autumn 1400 (67-84). [In Persian]
Bahrami, Farshad, Atashin Bar, Mohammad, (2018). Changes in the urban landscape of Hamadan during the first Pahlavi period; the effect of infiltrating streets on the center of Hamadan city. March, Bagh Nazar Scientific Journal, 5-14. [In Persian]
Bonds, Michael,( 2018).  Urban social theory. Translated by Dr. Rahmatullah Sediq Sarostani. University of Tehran. Publication Institute. [In Persian]
Pakzad, Jahanshah (1383), Guideline for the design of urban spaces in Iran, Ministry of Housing and Urban Development, Deputy of Urban Planning and Architecture, Secretariat of the Supreme Council of Urban Planning and Architecture. [In Persian]
Pertoi, Parvin, Shojaei, Delaram, Shojaei (2014). Effective factors on the creation and promotion of sociability in public spaces with different scales in Tehran, a case example: public spaces of two neighborhoods and one district in Region 7. Bagh Nazar Journal, No. 34. [In Persian]
Tibbalds, Francis (2013), citizen-oriented urbanization, translated by Mohammad Ahmadinejad, Nashrakhak. [In Persian]
Khairuddin, Reza, Haq Bayan, Reza, Shokohi Bidhandi, Mohammad Saleh (2018). Re-examining the failure components of the experience of creating a pedestrian walkway, 17 Shahrivar Street, Bagh Nazar, Tehran, No. 16, page 51-60. [In Persian]
Saket Hasanlui, Maitham, Naqibi, Fereydon, Asadi, Hiva (1401). Analysis of pedestrian capability; movement in strengthening the identity and social cohesion of cities, a case study: a comparative analysis of the central context of Naqdeh and Qorveh cities. Human Geography Research, Volume 54, Number 2, (1401(633-652. [In Persian]
Sajjadzadeh, Hassan, Mishtada, Mohammad (2019). Analysis of the effective factors in the quality of urban sidewalks from the citizens' point of view (case study: Hamadan Boali sidewalk). Urban Planning Geography Research, Volume 8, Number 3. (577-596. [In Persian]
Chaway, Françoise (2016). The book of urban planning, imagination and reality. [In Persian]
Sheikh Hosni, Hossein, Moradifar, Amir, Pourkhodadad, Behnaz (1400). Evaluating the effects of sidewalk construction on improving communication and social interactions of citizens (case study: Rasht city sidewalk). Scientific Quarterly Journal of Urban Ecology Research, Year 12, Number 2, Number 24, 33-48. [In Persian]
Rajabi, Fatemeh, Zare, Leila, Hosseini, Seyyed Baqer (1401). Synergism of cognitive maps technique and space layout in identification and analysis of sociability of physical spaces under the influence of spatial territories (case example: Shahrek Ekbatan, Tehran). Bagh Nazar Scientific Journal. June 1401. 19(108).5-16. [In Persian]
Rahimi, Leila, Sabouri, Saber (2017). The effect of climate on citizens' mental schemas in the perception of urban space, a case example: Tabriz's Eel Goli Park, Journal of Geography and Environmental Planning, No. 3, Fall 2017. [In Persian]
Ravanbakhsh, Ahmed, Mirabadi, Mustafa. 2017. Explanation and analysis of sociability in urban parks with the role of land and demographic factors (case example: Yasouj city beach park). 33 consecutive issues, 9 research and urban planning publications. [In Persian]
Sadeghi, Alireza, Dadgar, Massoud, Pourjafar, Ali, Neshat Aftian, Negin (2016). Iranian Islamic City Studies, No. 8, page 21-36. [In Persian]
Alitager, Saeed, Saadati Waqar, Pouria, Heydari, Ahmed, Farkhi, Amir Mohammad, Sajjadzadeh, Hassan (2018). Measuring the sociability of the urban environment through the matching of cognitive maps and spatial configuration maps. Utopia architecture and urban planning. Summer 2018, No. 7. Pages 99 to 109.. [In Persian]
Kashanijo, Khashayar, Mohammadi, Hamed (2019). Evaluating the effect of creating a pedestrian walkway on the volume of vehicular traffic on the surrounding roads (case example: pedestrian area of ​​15 Khordad, Tehran). Environmental Science and Technology, Volume 22, Number One, April 2019. [In Persian]
Kannouni, Reza, Razovian, Mohammad Taghi, 2017. Social and economic effects of sidewalk construction in Tehran city from the citizens' point of view (case study: 17 Shahrivar sidewalk). The scientific quarterly of the Faculty of Civil Engineering, Architecture and Art. The identity of the city. Pages 19-34. [In Persian]
Gehl, Yan (2007), Life in the space between buildings, translated by Shima Shasti, Jihad University Publishing Organization[In Persian]
Madanipour, Ali (1382). Urban planning and design of public spaces in the city. Journal of urban and rural management, number 14, page 70-75. [In Persian]
Mohseni Tashekand, Iraj, (2019). The title of the experience of pedestrian construction in the historical center of the city, the case study of the central square of Trabzon, Turkey. Shabak specialized scientific journal. Sixth year, number 2. [In Persian]
Moini, Seyyed Mehdi (2018). Pedestrian cities. Azarakhsh Publications. [In Persian]
Hashemi, Sima, Abbasi Azar, Sudabah (1400). City road, living road. Nesler Roshan Publications. [In Persian]
Arefi, A. (2007). “Place and Placelessness as Narrative Lf Loss: Rethinking the Notion of Place.” In the Journal of Urban Design. 4 (2): 179–193.
Bentley, Ian (1985). Responsive Environments.
Bounds, Michael, (2004). Urban social theory: city, self, and society.
Carmona, matthew, (2010).contemporary puplic space, part two: classification, hournal of urban design.
Carmona, M., S. Tiesdell, T. Heath, and T. Oc. (2010). Public Spaces—Urban Spaces: The Dimensions of Urban Design. Amsterdam: Elsevie
Carmona, M., Heath, T., Oc, T., & Tiesdell, S. (2012). Public places-Urban spaces (m. A. Shokohi, Zahra. Salehi, Esmail, Trans.): Tehran, University of Art.
Ewing, R., and O. Clemente. (2013). Measuring Urban Design. Washington, DC: Island Press.
Gehl, J. (2010). Cities for People. Washington: Island Press.
Gehl, J. (2011). Life between buildings: using public space (A. K. Ghafari, Freshteh. Mehrabi, Nastaran, Trans. Z. Varesi Ed.): Tehran, Parham Naqsh.
Gehl J. (2016). Life between buildings. Washington D.C.: Island Press.
Golany, Gideon S., Ojima, (1996). Geo-Space Urban Design 1st edition by Toshio Hardcove
Geurs, K. T. & Ritsema van Eck, J. R. (2001). Accessibility measures: reviewand applications. Evaluation of accessibility impacts of land-use transportation scenarios, and related social and economic impact. RIVM report no.408505-006, Bilthoven.
Harvey, C., and L. Aultman-Hall. (2016). “Measuring Urban Streetscapes for Livability: Review of Approaches.” in The Professional Geographer 68 (1): 149–158.
Hashemi Nima, Farnaz Emami, Parinaz Abdshahzadeh & Ali Asghar Niaei, (2022). The impact of physical components of the environment on the sociability of culturalrecreational spaces case study: Rasht cultural complex..HBRC Journal
HillIer, B. (1996). Space is the Machine. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hillier, B., & Vaughan, L. (2007). The City as one thing. Progress in Planning, 67)3(, 205-230.
Jacobs, Jane(1996), The uses of sidewalks: safty from the death and life of great American cities in legates, R. stout, F. the city reader, routledge, London, pp. 103-9.
Jimenez, Carmen Egea, Ospin, Edwar Leonardo Salamanca (2020). Sociabilidades en las plazas de Buenos Aires. Usos, usuarios y diseno urbano Sociabilities on the town squares of Buenos Aires. Uses, users and urban design. Estudios Demográficos y Urbanos. 517-556.
Karami, S.; Fakhrayee, A. & Karami, S. (2015). Studying the Effect of Accessibility and Vitality on Urban Space Efficiency in Iran (Case Study: Hamedān City). International Journal of Architecture and Urban Development, 5(1), 33-40.
Kim, H.K., & Sohn, D.W. (2002). An Analysis of the Relationship between Land Use Density of Office Buildings and Urban Street Configuration; Case Studies of Two Areas in Seoul by Space Syntax Analysis. Cities, 19(6), 409- 418.
Kwok, R. C. & Yeh, A. G. (2004).The use of modal accessibility gap as an indicator for sustainable transport development. Environment and Planning A, 36(5), 921-936.
Levine, J., & Garb, Y. (2002).Congestion pricing's conditional promise: promotion of accessibility or mobility?. Transport Policy, 9(3), 179-188
Long, Y.K., Baran, P., & Moore, R. (2007). The Role of Space Syntax in Spatial Cognition: Evidence from Urban China. Proceedings, 6th International Space Syntax Symposium, İstanbul
Luo, W. & Wang, F. (2003). Measures of spatial accessibility to health care in a GIS environment: synthesis and a case study in the Chicago region. Environment and Planning B, 30(6),865-884.
Naghibi, E., Habib, F., & Sabani, A. (2015). pedestrian area design to promote social interaction, case study: Isfahan khajoo neighborhood, international journal of architecture and urban development, 5(2), 31_42.
Relph, Edward, (1976). Place and Placelessness. London: Pion.
Relph, Edward, (1993). Modernity and the Reclamation of Place. In D. Seamon, ed, Dwelling, Seeing, and Designing: Toward a Phenomenological Ecology (pp. 25-40). Albany, NY: SUNY Press
Safari Hossein,n, Fakouri Moridani Fataneh (2017). Syntactical analysis of the accessibility and sociability of a square in the Kuala Lumpur City Center. Frontiers of Architectural Research.
Seamon David & Sowers Jacob. (2008). This commentary is published as a chapter in Key Texts in Human Geography, P. Hubbard, R. Kitchen, & G. Vallentine, eds., London: Sage, 2008, pp. 43-51 © David Seamon & Jacob Sowers Place and Placelessness, Edward Relph
Southworth M. (2005). Reinventing main street: from mall to townscape mall, Journal of Urban Design, Vol. 10, No. 2, pp. 151-170.
Tibbalds, F. (1992). Making people-frendly towns. Improving the public environment in towns and cities Spon Press, London, 2.
Urry, (1991) The Turist Gaze, Sage, London.
Yadegari, zohre,Alinaghi, behnoud. (2020). The effect of introversion and Extroverts of individuals in the socialization of public space. Technium Social Sciences Journal Vol. 3, 82-93.
www.pps.org
www.shabestan.ir
www.googleearthpro.ir
www.doyayesafar.com